Wal-Mart: Prices aren't the only thing they're keeping down Print E-mail
Written by Laryn   
Wednesday, 06 April 2005 23:48
Wal-Mart smiley editorial photo by Laryn Bakker)

"...Look behind that yellow smiley face and see what's really happening to workers...that poor guy making $15, $16 an hour, now he's [going to be] making a fraction of that, $7, $8 an hour, working 32 hours a week; a meager health care plan that he's got to pay for now, token health care plan; no pension; no future...That's what's happening [behind] that big, yellow smiley face."
-Jon Lehman, Former Wal-Mart store manager

Wal-Mart makes $285 billion in sales around the world each year in more than 5000 stores. Each year they account for about 2% of the GDP in the US. Lately they've been a pretty big punching bag for a lot of people, with a few stalwart defenders (including themselves and my father-in-law). Most of the defense-of-Wal-Mart arguments I hear have to do with their legendary low prices (economy of scale) and their efficiency (which revolutionized our economy). It's great that they are so efficient and have come up with new ways of streamlining business. But business is about more than efficiency--it's also about people (or it should be). And it's great that they are keeping the prices low. But to get their low prices, they're often forgetting about people again. And prices aren't the only thing they're keeping down...

Wal-Mart keeps down third world workers

Wal-Mart's network of suppliers (about 10,000) is constantly squeezed to lower their prices, so they continually scour the earth for places that can provide the labor cheaper and cheaper, battling with the other suppliers to come in the lowest. Each step of the chain of buying provides other opportunities for someone to cut a corner, or for someone to anonymously take advantage of disadvantaged, desperate people. Click

Wal-Mart keeps down unions

[Added 4/12/05] What would happen if a union formed in a Wal-Mart store? They shut it down. "Wal-Mart's decision to close the store reflects the retailer's deeply rooted aversion to unions, and its worries that organized labor had nearly established a beachhead, said Burt Flickinger III of Strategic Resource Group, a consulting firm specializing in retailing and consumer goods.

But he said the move could backfire for Wal-Mart, which has worked hard to counter a wave of bad publicity and portray itself as a generous employer."

"In the last few years, well over 100 unfair labor practice charges have been lodged against Wal-Mart throughout the country, with 43 charges filed in 2002 alone. Since 1995, the U.S. government has been forced to issue at least 60 complaints against Wal-Mart at the National Labor Relations Board. (International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU), Internationally Recognised Core Labour Standards in the United States: Report for the WTO General Council Review of the Trade Policies of the United States (Geneva, January 14-16, 2004)."
"In 2000, when a small meatcutting department successfully organized a union at a Wal-Mart store in Texas, Wal-Mart responded a week later by announcing the phase-out of its in-store meatcutting company-wide. Pan Demetrakakes, "Is Wal-Mart Wrapped in Union Phobia?" Food & Packaging 76 (August 1, 2003). Rather than comply, Wal-Mart is appealing this decision. (Dan Kasler, "Labor Dispute Has Historical Precedent," Scripps Howard News Service (November 3, 2003)."
"Wal-Mart has issued "A Manager's Toolbox to Remaining Union Free," which provides managers with lists of warning signs that workers might be organizing, including "frequent meetings at associates' homes" and "associates who are never seen together start talking or associating with each other."[7] The "Toolbox" gives managers a hotline to call so that company specialists can respond rapidly and head off any attempt by employees to organize." (Click)

Wal-Mart keeps down health care benefits

There was an article in the Post today about recently passed legislation in Maryland with requires Wal-Mart to increase the amount of money they put towards health care for their workers. The bill would require "organizations with more than 10,000 employees to spend at least 8 percent of their payroll on health benefits -- or put the money directly into the state's health program for the poor." It might seem like this bill unfairly targets Wal-Mart, but that's mostly because they're the only ones that don't meet the standard: three other organizations are large enough to be bound by this bill, but they all already meet the threshold.

Wal-Mart keeps down women

Wal-Mart has a history of paying women less than men, discriminating in training practices and of passing over women for promotions (2/3 of their workforce is women...1/10 of their management is). Now they've got a class action lawsuit against them, which covers more than 1.5 million women who have worked or currently do work for Wal-Mart. (See here or here).

Wal-Mart keeps down our communities

Here are summaries of a few studies done on the Wal-Mart big box impact on rural communities and on counties:

"Rural communities have been losing retail sales to larger towns ever since Montgomery Ward and Sears Roebuck started their mail order businesses. However, the leakage of retail trade from small towns has accelerated in the last two decades with the rapid proliferation of discount mass merchandiser stores in the larger towns and cities. Studies in Iowa have shown that some towns below 5,000 population have lost nearly half their retail trade in the last 13 years. Public officials are placed in difficult situations as they decide whether to recruit and/or approve the establishment of new mass merchandiser stores. There is a need for an educational program aimed at public officials, to help them make better decisions regarding this problem." (Increasing Understanding of Public Problems and Policies, 1997, "Impact of the Wal-Mart Phenomenon on Rural Counties" (PDF))

"Wal-Mart has created tremendous economic benefits for consumers by providing more choices at lower prices, especially in communities that had only local retail monopolies prior to the chain?s arrival. Yet no retailer evokes stronger negative emotions than this chain. Recent media attention has focused on questionable labor practices and other impacts of the stores, while academic studies have examined impacts on retail wages, employment levels and existing stores. Missing from the literature is an analysis of whether the ?Wal-Mart effect? is large enough to influence community-wide poverty rates. We find, after controlling for other factors determining changes in the poverty rate over time, that both counties with more initial (1987) Wal-Mart stores and with more additions of stores between 1987 and 1998 experienced greater increases (or smaller decreases) in family poverty rates during the 1990s economic boom period. We offer three possible explanations for this finding, including that Wal-Mart stores destroy civic capacity in the communities in which they locate by driving out local entrepreneurs and community leaders." (Center for Economic and Community Development (Penn State), October 2004, Wal-Mart and County-Wide Poverty (PDF))

Wal-Mart keeps down the American taxpayer

"Due to low pay and lack of health care, Wal-Mart employees are eligible for federal assistance. The estimated total amount of federal assistance for which Wal-Mart employees were eligible in 2004 was $2.5 billion (?Harper?s Index,? Harper?s Magazine, Vol. 310, No. 1858, 3/2005) According to a study by the Institute for Labor and Employment at the University of California-Berkeley, California taxpayers subsidized $20.5 million worth of medical care for Wal-Mart in that state alone.[48] In fact, Wal-Mart personnel offices, knowing employees cannot afford the company health plan, actually encourage employees to apply for charitable and public assistance, according to a recent report by the PBS news program Now With Bill Moyers.[49]
...
The Democratic Staff of the Committee on Education and the Workforce estimates that one 200-person Wal-Mart store may result in a cost to federal taxpayers of $420,750 per year ? about $2,103 per employee." (Click).

"The single-minded pursuit of economic growth can exact a heavy toll on a community. Our economic goal of creating wealth should coincide with our ideals of human and societal development." (Batstone and Chandler) So, too, a single-minded "obligation to provide the lowest price of goods" (Ray Bracey, Wal-Mart Vice President for Federal and International Corporate Affairs) will keep the prices down, but will also keep down the dignity of many people.

Is the man keeping you down? Add your comments below the links, or discuss here.

Other Links (updated periodically):

  • Wake-up Wal-Mart (link): "The "Wake-Up Wal-Mart Campaign" is about Americans joining together in common purpose to change Wal-Mart. There is only one force powerful enough to change the #1 Fortune 500 company in the world ? the American people."
  • Is Wal-Mart Good for America? (link): "Wal-Mart's "everyday low prices" benefit millions of American consumers, and it is Fortune magazine's number-one most admired company in the United States. But others argue that Wal-Mart is a bad bargain for American workers."
  • Cultivate Three Rivers Initiative: Wal-Mart related Resources (link): "Citizens should be engaging in serious dialogue about whether Wal-Mart will be a positive or a negative addition to the...community."
  • Wal-Mart Litigation Project (link): "A guide for lawyers preparing to sue the company."
  • Wal-Mart Fact Checker (link): "Analyzes Wal-Mart ads for truthfullness"
  • Up Against Wal-Mart (link): "At the world's largest and most profitable retailer, low wages, unpaid overtime, and union busting are a way of life. Now Wal-Mart workers are fighting back."
  • The Wal-Mart Effect (link): "When Wal-Mart Stores Inc. demands a lower price for the shirts and shorts it sells by the millions, the consequences are felt in a remote Chinese industrial town, at a port in Bangladesh and here in Honduras, under the corrugated metal roof of the Cosmos clothing factory...Isabel Reyes, who has worked at the plant for 11 years, pushes fabric through her sewing machine 10 hours a day, struggling to meet the latest quota scrawled on a blackboard. She now sews sleeves onto shirts at the rate of 1,200 garments a day. That's two shirts a minute, one sleeve every 15 seconds..."There is always an acceleration," said Reyes, 37, who can't lift a cooking pot or hold her infant daughter without the anti-inflammatory pills she gulps down every few hours. "The goals are always increasing, but the pay stays the same."
  • Always Low Prices...Always? (link): [Added 4/18/05] The Best and the Worst About Walmart (blog).
  • The War on Walmart (link): A Wall Street Journal defense of the big box...for my father-in-law
  • Wal-Mart facts (link): "We understand that many of you want to know more about Wal-Mart. And we want you to know more about us..." Nothing we do is wrong. Everything you've heard is a lie...
  • Understanding the Wal-Mart Effect (link): [Added 4/13/05] An anecdotal analysis of a college town which proved resiliant against Wal-Mart leads this author to conclude that "the Wal-Mart effect is overwhelmingly beneficial."

blog comments powered by Disqus
 
RocketTheme Joomla Novus Template Info